I got new tall boots for my birthday, and I’ve been riding in them consistently for about a month now. (Tredstep Medicis, for the curious; I’ll do a review after some further breaking-in.) They are generally pretty great, but they have highlighted one huge flaw in my riding position.
Can you see it?
Apparently, I roll my feet to the outside in the stirrups. Something about the way these boots are holding my leg and ankle more stable means that rolling my foot to the outside compresses my little toe against the outside of the stirrup and after just a few minutes, starts to hurt like hell.
It’s pretty subtle, but you can see it more clearly in my left leg here.
I think it’s a combination of a couple of things. I am generally on the tall side for Tristan, and I’ve ridden him in spurs for a long time, which means I’ve developed the bad habit of curling my leg up and in to cue driving aids. The way I’ve apparently accomplished that is to weight the outside of my foot, which causes my foot to slide to the outside of the stirrup, which means that posting puts pressure down in the bottom outside corner of the stirrup.
I’m also, admittedly, not as secure in the stirrup as I should be – really weighting my leg down into a dressage length of stirrup. Getting better at that would mean the stirrups move around less, and have less chance to move into that awkward position. There may also be some pinching with the knee mixed up in this whole thing, and I know that rolling my foot like this was also an old flaw with my jumping position – it felt more secure cross-country.
It doesn’t help that my stirrup treads were shot years ago, and are basically providing no grip to speak of.
I’m a bit stumped on how to fix it. I have a few ideas, but would appreciate additional suggestions!
So far I’ve been trying:
- Consciously working not to curl my leg and foot, which is hard, because it wasn’t something I realized I was doing in the first place. I’m trying to think about weighting the ball of my foot more, aligning my posting through the big toe instead of the little toe. I’m not at all sure that’s the right way to visualize it, though.
- Looking into replacing my stirrup treads. Right now, I just have basic Fillis irons with rubber inserts that are basically flat. It looks like I can replace them with the same, or “upgrade” to something like this. I don’t love the idea of it, but I also reallllly don’t want to buy new stirrups. (Though, if buying new stirrups would substantially improve my life, try to convince me.)
- Riding without stirrups. Which, okay, isn’t the worst temporary solution, but it’s not an actual fix for the problem.
Any ideas? Anyone else have this problem?
8 thoughts on “Bad Habit Theater: Rolling Feet in Stirrups”
ooooh those boots are PRETTY tho! i think with such pretty boots, you definitely can make the case for upgrading your irons 😉
personally i saw a big difference with lighter weight irons – my dressage saddle currently has the compositi reflex irons on (they retail at < $50). i've used them for years and feel like they reduce the likelihood of losing my stirrup while riding, and also allow my leg to hang where it needs to vs being pulled any which way by a heavy iron. plus it's shocking to me how much lighter my saddle is to carry around too. my jump saddle has light weight aluminum stubben irons with some seriously grippy teeth on the treads, and that's been helpful for keeping my foot securely in place on the stirrup bed. so…. long story short, different irons may help out haha.
I can only ride in jointed stirrups or my knees rebel so no help there. I’m REALLY bad about only weighting the outside of my foot, and having BM constantly harp at me to weight the entire ball of my foot has made a huge help in keeping my foot positioned evenly across the stirrup.
I replaced the stirrup pads on my jumping saddle’s regular fillis irons with Super Comfort Iron Pads (https://www.smartpakequine.com/pt/super-comfort-iron-pads-6038) a few years ago and have been really impressed with how grippy they are! They help me keep my foot securely in the stirrup without driving it all the home in the iron (which is my personal bad stirrup habit).
I find that I do that same thing in newer boots but not in older ones. So it may just go away as you get those boots broken in.
I would replace those stirrup pads either way though! I personally hate those cheese grater ones. They’re almost too grippy, and if you’re not careful when you put your irons up, they shred your leathers. I like the ones that are similar to yours, but have sand paper in the middle. Gives more grip but not so sharp.
You could try something like these….
Hey, i have recently found the same problem and i find it causes me to become really in-balanced and tends to hurt so please tell me if you find something that worked and i have never had a problem before and been riding in my boots for about 2 years!
Yes! I switched to tech stirrups – light plastic ones – and the problem went away. I bought these and have been riding in them since: https://www.ridingwarehouse.com/Compositi_Premium_Lightweight_Stirrup_Irons_4_3_4/descpage-COPL.html